Property that Cannot be Transferred: Non-Transferable Property

Introduction:

An owner has three primary rights in the property. These include the right of ownership, the right of possession and enjoyment, and the right of alienation with respect to the property. The third right includes the right to transfer property. However, Section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, enumerates certain properties that cannot be transferred. These enumerated properties are non-transferable property.

Chance to Acquire Property:

The law prohibits an heir from transferring a chance to succeed to property. The property can be estate or legacy upon the death of a kinsman. This is so because the owner can sell the property while alive or assign it to others in a will. Even the heir may die before the owner of property. That’s why the heir is apparent.  The transfer of a chance to succeed property is void ab initio. The transfer of an interest arising in future is also prohibited. For example, property in a partition dispute is non-transferable

Moreover, any other future hope or expectancy in property is not transferable, like prize money that may be won in lottery.

Pexels Image by RDNE Stock Project

A Right of Re-entry:

The property owner cannot transfer the re-entry right to another person on breach of a condition. For example, C transfers a partial right of warehouse to B for a certain purpose on the condition that C has re-entry right in the warehouse if B uses the property for non-assigned purpose. This C’s re-entry right is non-transferable. If C does that, it becomes void.

Easement:

An owner of the property has right to beneficial enjoyment of certain other land that is not his own. This is an easement right. It is a non-profitable privilege. For example, a property owner’s right of way over another’s land to access the commuter road is an easement right. It is also non-transferable.

Interest Restricted to Personal Enjoyment:

Any property interest which is restricted to its owner, personally, in property enjoyment cannot be transferred by him. This includes priestly offices or emoluments attached to it, the office of shebait of a temple. Another case, when two siblings partition property and give each other a preferential right to buy the portion if either wants to sell. This preferential right is non-transferable to any other person.

Right to Future Maintenance:

The right to future maintenance cannot be transferred because it defeats the very purpose of maintenance laws. It is restricted to that person only.

Mere Right to Sue:

Mere right to sue is a right to sue in relation to property without any interest in it. Such a right is non-transferable. Property, interest in property and right to sue are distinct. Thus, the right to recover damages or sue should accompany the interest in property.

However, a decree is transferable. This means the Claimant’s legal heirs are entitled to claim the compensation issued in the decree.

Office, Salary and Stipends:

A public office and the salary are non-transferable property, so is the pension. A salary is a return for personally rendered service and therefore cannot be transferred. Likely, the government servant has a civil right, a lien, on his appointed post, which cannot be transferred. Pension is also non-transferable, as long as it is unpaid or with the government.

However, stipends are non-transferable, as they are provided for past services or as compensation to dethroned princes.

Opposed to the Nature of Interest:

If the transfer of property affects or opposes the nature of interest in the property, it cannot be transferred. Things dedicated to public or religious use and regalia are such examples.

Unlawful Object or Consideration:

This restriction is aligned with Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. It prohibits the transfer of property for an unlawful object as well as any unlawful consideration for the property. Transferring property on the condition that one continues an immoral relationship is such an example.

Person Legally Disqualified:

The property is non-transferable to a legally disqualified person. For example, if an officer is assigned to sell a property, he cannot buy the same for himself. He is legally disqualified to purchase it.

Statutory Prohibition:

It acknowledges the laws or statutes which prohibit any transfer of property. For example, a tenant’s occupancy right is not transferable under different enactments. It is an exception to the general rule that all tenancies or leaseholds are transferable.

Conclusion:

Alienation rei prefertur juri accrescendi, which means law favours alienation to accumulation, however, Section 6 restricts certain property transfers. This prohibits the transfer of non-existing title to property or title that does not belong to that person. This does not apply when the person has subsisting legal title at the time of transfer but may not have physical possession. However, public office is not for consideration in a transfer.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *