Introduction
A confession made by one accused person may become relevant during the trial of another person who is accused of participating in the same offence. Such a confession is known as the confession of a co-accused. It is an important concept under Indian evidence law because it raises questions regarding the admissibility, reliability, and evidentiary value of statements made by individuals who are jointly tried for an offence.
The law treats such confessions cautiously because a person may make a statement to protect themselves, shift responsibility, or implicate another person. Therefore, specific legal conditions must be satisfied before a confession made by a co-accused can be considered by the court.
Section 24 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023
Section 24 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA), 2023, deals with the consideration of a proved confession affecting the person making it and others jointly under trial for the same offence.
Under this provision, when two or more persons are being jointly tried for the same offence, and a confession made by one of them affects both the maker and another accused, the court may take that confession into consideration against the other accused as well as the person who made it.
This provision substantially corresponds to Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which governed the same subject under the earlier evidence law.

Essential Conditions for Considering Confession of Co-Accused
Certain essential conditions must be fulfilled before a confession can be considered against a co-accused:
1. Joint Trial: The accused persons must be jointly tried for the same offence. A confession made during a separate trial generally cannot be considered against another person under this provision.
2. Confession Must Be Proved: The statement must qualify as a confession and be proved before the court in accordance with the law. A mere accusation or statement implicating another person does not automatically qualify as a confession.
3. It Must Affect the Maker and the Co-Accused: The confession must implicate the person making it and also affect another accused who is jointly tried in the same case.
4. Same Offence: The accused persons must be jointly tried for the same offence, rather than merely facing unrelated charges in separate proceedings.
5. Judicial Discretion: The provision states that the court may take the confession into consideration. Therefore, the court is not automatically bound to rely on it.
Evidentiary Value of a Co-Accused’s Confession
A confession made by a co-accused is not substantive evidence against another accused in the same way as direct evidence. It occupies a weaker evidentiary position and must be approached with considerable caution.
In Kashmira Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1952), the Supreme Court explained the limited evidentiary value of a co-accused’s confession. The Court emphasised that such a confession should not ordinarily form the foundation of a conviction. Instead, the court should first examine the other evidence independently and consider whether the confession provides support for an already established conclusion.
Similarly, in Haricharan Kurmi v. State of Bihar (1964), the Supreme Court clarified that a co-accused’s confession is not substantive evidence and cannot independently sustain a conviction. It may be considered as an additional circumstance, but the court must first evaluate the evidence available against the accused independently.
These decisions highlight the principle that a person’s guilt should not be established solely on the basis of another accused person’s confession.
Difference Between a Confession and an Accusation
A confession involves an admission of guilt or substantially all the facts constituting an offence by the person making the statement. An accusation, on the other hand, merely alleges that another person committed the offence.
This distinction is significant because Section 24 applies to a confession, not every statement made by an accused person. Courts must examine the substance of the statement rather than merely its wording.
Conclusion
The confession of a co-accused under Section 24 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, is a significant rule of evidence that permits courts to consider certain confessions during joint trials. However, its evidentiary value remains limited, and it cannot ordinarily serve as the sole basis for conviction. The principles established in Kashmira Singh and Haricharan Kurmi reinforce the need for independent evidence and careful judicial scrutiny. Ultimately, this provision seeks to balance the relevance of a co-accused’s confession with the fundamental principle that criminal guilt must be established through reliable evidence.
Written by:
Nisha Das


Motive And Intention In Criminal Law: Why Courts Treat Them Differently - Legal Insaan
[…] In circumstantial cases, a proved motive can strengthen the chain of events, and its absence does not automatically break that chain. Put simply, motive and intention play different roles at trial: motive can be a clue to intention, never a substitute for it. For a related look at how courts handle evidence in criminal trials, read our blog on confession of co-accused. […]
Disclosure Statement: Section 23 BSA, 2023 - Legal Insaan
[…] the terms are sometimes used together, a disclosure statement and a confession are legally […]