The meaning of Spes Successionis, the Latin Doctrine, means the expectation, chance or hope of a legal heir to inherit property in the future from the actual owner/ someone who is still alive.
This does not give any actual legal claim or right to that property.
The heir has no vested or ownership interest that exists in the present to claim while the owner is alive as ‘a living man has no heirs’
Why? The logic behind the Doctrine
The doctrine depends on a future possibility arrangement yet to be legalized or formalized through a registered will. The heir may die before the owner and the property in question may never come to him, The owner can make a decision to sell or gift the property. They can write the property in someone else’s favour entirely, an existing will that originally favored the heir can also be changed/modified into transferring the property to someone else while the transferror/owner is still alive.
Thus, Spes Successionis is non-transferable, i.e. the heir has nothing real to transfer and thus the transfer is void.
Legal Framework /Law in India
Spes Successionis is covered under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
Under this Section 6 deals with what may or may not be transferred and specifically says :
“The chance of an heir-apparent succeeding to an estate, the chance of a relation obtaining a legacy on the death of a living relative, or any other mere possibility of a like nature, cannot be transferred.”
Thus, Transfer of mere hope or possibility by the heir is a transaction void-ab-initio i.e invalid from the very beginning.
Section 6 vs Section 43 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882
Doctrine of Feeding the Grant by Estoppel dealt under Section 43: If a legatee/future heir sells or transfers a property they do not actually have the ownership of/do not actually own, while falsely claiming ownership at the time of such transaction, the transfer becomes valid later under this section/law if the legatee eventually acquires the right to that property.
Section 6 will be applicable in cases where the will is changed, or modified into transferring the property in someone else’s favor other than the heir or sold or gifted by the actual owner that is the arrangement or expected decision is changed.
Conclusion
The Doctrine of Spes Successionis should not be confused with a present legal claimable right or contingent interest, it is a future possibility of inheritance of the property in question, subject to prevailing conditions, and this principle applies to the period before the death of the transferor/owner of property not after the death or when the transfer has already occurred.
Spes successionis reminds us that the law protects what a person actually owns today, not what they merely hope to inherit tomorrow.
Written By
Lehar Agarwal

