Motive and Intention in Criminal Law: Why Courts Treat Them Differently

  • Home
  • Uncategorized
  • Motive and Intention in Criminal Law: Why Courts Treat Them Differently

Ask anyone what separates a killer from someone who caused a death by accident, and they will probably say, “the reason behind it.” That answer is only half right. Motive and intention are two different things in criminal law, and confusing them can change the outcome of a trial. The Supreme Court has been untangling this for decades, and it did so again in 2025. This blog explains how intention and motive differ, why courts care, and what the recent cases tell us.

Motive and Intention Differences

Motive is the why: revenge, greed, jealousy, fear. Intention is the what: the decision to kill, hurt or steal. If A kills B over an old business grudge, the grudge is the motive and the decision to cause B’s death is the intention. In Basdev v. State of Pepsu (1956), the Supreme Court explained that motive is what prompts a person to form an intention, while knowledge is simply awareness of the consequences. Motive and intention often show up together, but the law treats them as separate questions.

motive and intention in criminal law
Image generated by Chatgpt

Why Intention Matters More for Liability

Most serious offences require a guilty mind, and that usually means intention or knowledge. Whether a killing is murder or the lesser culpable homicide often depends on it. In Anbazhagan v. State (2023), the accused struck his neighbour once on the head with a farm tool during a quarrel over a pathway. The Court held that he could be said to know death was likely, but not that he intended the fatal injury. The conviction came down to Section 304 Part II of the IPC.

Nobody can see inside another person’s mind. So courts work backwards from the weapon, the part of the body targeted, the force used, and what happened before and after.

Intention and Motive as Evidence

This is where motive earns its place. It is not an ingredient of an offence, so the prosecution can succeed without proving it if the rest of the evidence holds. But it is a relevant fact. Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act made motive, preparation and conduct relevant, and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 now carries the same rule in Section 6.

In circumstantial cases, a proved motive can strengthen the chain of events, and its absence does not automatically break that chain. Put simply, motive and intention play different roles at trial: motive can be a clue to intention, never a substitute for it. For a related look at how courts handle evidence in criminal trials, read our blog on confession of co-accused.

What Chunni Bai Teaches About Motive and Intention

In Chunni Bai v. State of Chhattisgarh (2025), a mother was convicted of murder for killing her two young daughters with an iron rod. Eyewitnesses proved the act. What was missing was any reason for it. Witnesses described her as a loving mother, and she claimed to be under some unseen influence.

The Supreme Court said that where direct evidence links the accused to the crime, absence of motive does not prevent conviction. But where the motive that could explain the intention is completely missing, courts must be careful before inferring intention. It converted the conviction to Section 304 Part II.

The case is a clear illustration of intention and motive working together: motive cannot replace proof of intention, but its complete silence can make intention harder to prove.

Conclusion: Keeping Motive and Intention Apart

Motive explains conduct, while intention decides culpability. A missing motive will not save an accused when the evidence is strong, and a strong motive will not convict anyone without proof of what they actually meant to do. The move to the BNS and BSA gives no reason to think courts will treat motive and intention any differently going forward.

Written by

Lehar Agarwal

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *