Delhi High Court Judgments in July

This blog covers three judgments from the Delhi High Court’s July adjudications. The first judgment determines whether compliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 is mandatory for a Counter-Claim Suit. The second judgment relates to cheque dishonour proceedings after a settlement agreement. Whereas, the third judgment determines the legal status of an arbitration clause after the change in corporate name.

Counter Claim and Pre-Institution Mediation under Section 12A:

Case Name: Vijay V. Havells India Limited & Ors (FAO(COMM) 46 2025).

Bench: Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Amit Mahajan.

Case Outlines: In this case, the Delhi High Court held that the requirement of pre-institution mediation depends on the Claims in the Counter-Claim Suit. The objective of the Act, 2015 is the expeditious disposal. When the parties in pre-institution mediation of the pending commercial suit have considered the claims of the Counter Claim, then further pre-mediation is not required. If the claims of the Counter Claim were not part of mediation of the pending commercial suit, then independent compliance with Section 12A is required. Further, if mediation proceedings did not take place in the pending suit, then pre-institution of mediation is indispensable.

Pre-institution mediation is intended to facilitate the settlement of disputes before litigation commences. The requirement of a second round of mediation in respect of counter-claims that were already part of earlier mediation is contrary to the objective of expeditious commercial adjudication.

Pexel Image by Katrin Bolovtsova: Judgment

Pexel Image by Katrin Bolovtsova

Preservation of Cheque Dishonour Proceedings After Settlement Agreement:

Case Name: M/S Flywheel Logistics Pvt Ltd. v. Apace Transco Pvt Ltd. & Ors. (2026 DHC 5209).

Bench: Justice Amit Mahajan.

Case Outlines: This case involves proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881, for dishonour of cheques in business payment settlement. The Petitioner transferred the payment liability to the sister company, which became insolvent. The NCLT, however, did not count the Respondent as operational creditor of the sister company, thus, no payment settlement took place. Thereafter, all three, including the sister company, entered into settlement for payment and to suspend the Respondent’s legal rights ‘temporarily’ for legal proceedings under Section 138.

However, the payment never took place, and the Respondent continued the proceedings under Section 138. Aggrieved by the continuation of proceedings, the Petitioner preferred the petition before the Delhi High Court.

The High Court in the present case held that the Parties prima facie appeared to have decided to preserve the NI Act proceedings. The pursuit of the civil remedy against the sister company in NCLT does not ipso facto quash the complaint. Further, stated that the offence is made out once the cheque in question is dishonoured. The primary goal of NI Act proceedings is to protect the victim’s financial interests, and subsequent assignment of debt to a sister company does not invalidate liability, especially when the terms of settlement and assignment prima facie provide for such exception.

Legal Status of an Arbitration Clause on a Corporate Name Change:

Case Name: Newgen IT Technologies Ltd v Newgen Software Technologies Ltd Case (FAO (COMM) 112/2025 &CM APPL. 27327/2025)

Bench: Justices C. Hari Shankar and Om Prakash Shukla.

Case Outlines: In this case, a Partner Agreement was executed to confer a right on the Appellant to use the “NEWGEN” mark. The Partner Agreement proscribed use of the “NEWGEN” mark in any manner which infringe the registered trademarks of the Respondent. The Appellant, however, changed its corporate name to “NEWGEN IT TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED”, which resulted in the infringement of Respondent’s trademark.

The Respondent filed a suit before the Commercial Court for infringement of its trademark. In it, the appellant filed an application under Section 8 of the A&C Act to refer the dispute to arbitration under the Partner Agreement. The Court dismissed the application on the ground that there was no agreement, as the Appellant Company’s name had changed. The Petitioner assailed the dismissal of the Section 8 application by filing an appeal before the Delhi High Court.

The Delhi High Court held that the mere change in the corporate name of one of the parties does not bring the contract between them to an end. The Court stated that if this were so, a party to a contract could, by merely changing its corporate name, stand excused of its liabilities under the contract. Therefore, the High set aside the order and referred the parties to arbitration.

Conclusion:

All three judgments entail different laws but are somehow affected by extrajudicial settlement. In the first judgment, the legislation itself prescribes mediation for settlement; in the second, the parties themselves entered into a settlement; and in the third, an arbitration agreement was in place. Extrajudicial settlements raise new questions for the existing laws.

Written by:
Sonali Ray

1 Comment

  • November 11, 2026

    Fake Judgments In Court: Decision Built On AI Hallucinations Is No Decision - Legal Insaan

    […] the foundation of a finding or were a stray addition, is a fair question for future cases. As the judgment stands, though, the Court’s words (“irrespective” of bearing) leave no room for […]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *