Section 63 BSA: Legal Status of Screenshots

Introduction 

In today’s digital world, important conversations, transactions, threats, agreements and other interactions often take place through smartphones and computers. As a result, screenshots of WhatsApp messages, social-media posts, emails, online transactions and other digital content are increasingly relied upon when people need to establish what happened. But an important question arises: Can a screenshot actually be used as evidence in court? Section 63 BSA clears the legal status of screenshots.

The answer is yes, screenshots can potentially be used as evidence in India, but their admissibility and evidentiary value depend on the circumstances in which they were created, preserved and produced. Courts may examine whether the screenshot is genuine, relevant and sufficiently connected to the facts of the case. 

Legal Status of Screenshots as Evidence: Section 63 BSA

Under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), electronic and digital records are recognised as evidence. Section 61 provides that an electronic or digital record cannot be denied admissibility merely because it is electronic or digital, subject to the requirements of the law. Section 62 specifically deals with proving the contents of electronic records, while Section 63 provides the requirements concerning admissibility of electronic records. 

A screenshot is essentially a copy or representation of information displayed on an electronic device. Depending on the circumstances, it may therefore form part of the electronic evidence placed before a court. However, simply taking a screenshot does not automatically establish that everything shown in it is authentic. 

A chat that suggests legal status of screenshots
Image by Mikhail Nilov from Pexels

What Makes a Screenshot More Reliable? 

The court may consider several factors when examining a screenshot. These can include the source of the information, the device from which it was obtained, the circumstances in which it was captured and whether the information has been altered. 

For example, a screenshot of a threatening message may be more useful when accompanied by the original conversation, the relevant device, account information or other evidence that helps establish who sent the message and when it was sent. 

It is therefore important to preserve the original digital material whenever possible. Instead of keeping only a cropped screenshot, a person should retain the complete conversation or webpage, including relevant dates, usernames, phone numbers or other identifying information. 

Importance of the Section 63 BSA Requirements 

Section 63 of the BSA sets out conditions concerning the admissibility of electronic records and also provides for a certificate to accompany electronic records when they are being submitted under that provision. The certificate is intended to identify the electronic record, describe how it was produced and provide relevant details concerning the device or computer system involved. 

This means that the legal process surrounding electronic evidence can be important even when the evidence appears straightforward. A screenshot should not be treated as automatically conclusive merely because it looks genuine. 

How Should Screenshots Be Preserved?

If a screenshot may later be required in legal proceedings, it is advisable to preserve the evidence carefully. Avoid editing, cropping or adding text to the image. Keep the original device and, where possible, retain the original message, email, post or webpage from which the screenshot was taken. 

It can also be useful to preserve related information such as the date and time, URL, account details, complete conversation and surrounding messages. Additional evidence, such as the original electronic device or relevant metadata, may help establish authenticity. 

Most importantly, a screenshot should be considered as one piece of evidence rather than automatically treated as conclusive proof. Its weight will depend on the facts and the manner in which it is proved. 

Conclusion 

Screenshots can play an important role in modern legal proceedings because much of everyday communication now occurs electronically. Indian law recognises electronic and digital records, subject to the applicable requirements for proving and admitting them. 

However, the usefulness of a screenshot depends on factors such as authenticity, relevance, integrity and the circumstances in which it was obtained and preserved. Anyone relying on a screenshot in a legal dispute should therefore preserve the original digital evidence and obtain appropriate legal advice about the requirements applicable to their particular case. 

Written by Nisha Das

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *