Difference Between Burden of Proof and Onus of Proof

Introduction:

In civil and criminal proceedings, parties are always either under the burden of proof or the onus of proof to prove their facts before the Court. The two terms refer to the obligation to prove their respective side but are fundamentally different. Where the burden of proof stays with a party, the onus of proof shifts from one side to the other as the case proceeds. Both are essential parts of the evidentiary framework.

What is the Burden of Proof?

It is a legal burden, as placed by statute on the parties. It is for asserting the existence of facts. The burden is said to lie on the person to prove the existence of certain facts on which seeking legal rights or claims depends. After introduction of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, in place of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, Sections 104 – 120 enumerate the provisions of burden of proof. As per Section 105, in a suit or proceedings, it lies on that person who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side. For example, the burden of proof lies on criminal prosecution to prove the commission of crime. This burden never shifts to the other party.

The Oscillating Onus of Proof:

The onus of proof is the shifting obligation on each party to produce evidence to prove any facts. Let’s understand it like this, assume a criminal case against the accused. The BNSS, 2023, places the burden on the prosecution to prove the commission of the offence beyond a reasonable doubt. This never shifts to the accused. The oscillation of the onus of proof begins at trial. The initial evidentiary onus is on the prosecution to establish a prima facie case. Thereafter, the onus shifts to the accused and, on successfully discharging it, back to the prosecution. Then, the Court adjudicates the matter and examines the fixed burden of proof.

Pexels Image by Brett Jordan

Burden Vs. Onus:

AspectBurden of proofOnus of proof
MeaningLegal duty to prove the case or a factDuty to lead evidence at a given stage
NatureFixed, stays with one partyShifts as evidence is led
Deciding factorPleadings and substantive lawState of the evidence at that point
When it mattersSettled at the start; decides the case if the record ends evenly balancedContinuously, during the trial

Landmark Judgment:

The Supreme Court in Anil Rishi Vs. Gurbaksh Sing (AIR 2006 SC 1971) observed the distinction between a burden of proof and onus of proof. It states that the burden of proof assumes importance in the early stage of a case. It is used in three ways: (i) to indicate the duty of bringing forward evidence in support of a proposition at the beginning or later; (ii) to make that of establishing a proposition as against all counter evidence; and (iii) an indiscriminate use in which it may mean either or both of the others. The elementary rule in Section 101 (of repealed IEA) is inflexible.

In terms of Section 102, the initial onus is always on the plaintiff, and if he discharges that onus and makes out a case which entitles him to a relief, the onus shifts to the defendant to prove those circumstances, if any, which would disentitle the plaintiff to the same.

Conclusion:

The general rule of burden of proof has an exception in NI Act, POSCO and NDPS laws. The static burden of proof and oscillating onus of proof are tools to move court proceedings. In criminal proceedings the burden of proof on prosecution is comparatively more strict than on plaintiff in civil proceedings. They provide a fair and equitable system to the Plaintiff/Prosecution and Defendant/Accused. Together, they create a mechanism to evaluate the evidence for adjudication of cases. However,

Written by:
Sonali Ray.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *