DNA Paternity Test vs Right to Privacy: What Does Indian Law Say?

  • Home
  • Educational
  • DNA Paternity Test vs Right to Privacy: What Does Indian Law Say?

Introduction:

We have seen on entertainment shows that when a person doubts the child’s parentage, the individual attempts to conduct a DNA Paternity Test secretly.  However, do you know how credible it is in law, or whether it can be used as evidence in Court? There is no straightforward answer. So, let’s understand what Indian Law says about it.

Parentage and Legitimacy:

It is important to understand first Paternity and Legitimacy before diving into DNA paternity testing against the right to privacy. Technically, Paternity and legitimacy have different meanings. This is because a child born during a valid marriage may not be the biological child of the parents. Paternity coincides with the biological relationship between a father and child, whereas legitimacy recognises the legal status of a child born during a valid marriage. Legitimacy has implications for inheritance and other legal rights.



Image generated by ChatGPT

Legitimacy of Child and DNA Paternal Testing:

The legitimacy presumption primarily arises from the maxim, “pater est quem nuptiae demonstrant“, which means, “he is the father whom the marriage indicates to be so”. In the Indian legal evidentiary framework, Section 116 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (formally Section 112 of the IEA, 1872) encapsulates the presumption of legitimacy for a child born during a valid marriage. It states that a child is decisively legitimate if he or she is born either:

–        during a valid marriage; or

–   within 280 days after the dissolution of marriage, when the mother remains unmarried.

Thus, the rule of evidence prohibits unreasonable interrogation to the child’s legitimacy born from valid marriage except in a certain condition. The degree of presumption in the section places legitimacy equivalent to paternity. This directly restrain the application of DNA paternity testing to determine paternity at first instance. 

However, the section provides that the child’s legitimacy can be questioned if the individuals in the marriage had no opportunity for marital relations when the mother conceived the child. This condition involves the question of the child’s paternity. So, can DNA testing determine the child’s legitimacy at this stage?

Supreme Court Judgments on DNA Paternity Testing:

The Indian Judiciary has very strict safeguards against the DNA Paternity Testing as evidence. Courts allow it to determine a child’s legitimacy when it is the only way. In Aparna Ajinkya Firodia v. Ajinkya Arun Firodia  (SLP 9855/2022), the Court, after analysing the judicial precedent, Bhabani Prasad (2010) and Dipanwita Roy (2015), enumerated the following rules:

–     DNA test should be permitted when there is sufficient initial evidence in favour of the person seeking such direction;

–     the test can be allowed to prove infidelity when there is no other mode of proving the allegations and it is necessary to prove;

–        it should not be ordered mechanically;

–  the paternity of the child is directly in issue, not collateral to proceedings.

Thus, the Court does not prioritise DNA testing as evidence to determine paternity for proving legitimacy. It considers the relevance of the test, the availability of other evidence, and its consequences on the parties.

DNA Paternal Testing as Evidence against Right to Privacy:

Article 21 of the Indian Constitution protects an individual’s life and personal liberty as a fundamental right. It includes the right to privacy, and the testing directly violates the rights of the child and the mother. However, K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (AIR 2017 SC 4161) does not recognise the right to privacy as an absolute right. It states the following threefold requirement for invasion of the right:

–      legality, which postulates the existence of law;

–       need, defined in terms of a legitimate State aim;

–     proportionality, which ensures a rational nexus between the objects and the means adopted to achieve them.

Then the judgment concluded that subjecting an individual forcefully to DNA testing is an intrusion into his privacy and personal liberty. The Court, however, can intrude only after satisfying the threefold test. Recently, the Court in Ivan Rathinam v. Milan Joseph, (2025 INSC 115) reiterated the threshold for DNA test. If we observe enumerated judicial rules for DNA test parallel to the threefold requirement against the right to privacy, we can find the following relation:

Threefold TestRules for DNA Paternity Test order
Existence of LawException in the presumption under Section 116 of BSA, that the parties have no access to each other
Legitimate AimPaternity must be directly in issue in the case or other legitimate objective.
ProportionalityIt should not be ordered mechanically but where no other evidence can resolve the issue and in the balance of interests of all parties.

Conclusion:

Thus, neither is the right to privacy absolute, nor can a DNA paternity test be ordered mechanically for evidence. Most importantly, a DNA paternity test puts the child’s dignity and privacy in the line of fire. This exposes the child to social stigma and disrespect. That is why the Court becomes reluctant to allow the test as evidence at the first instance and permits it in exceptional cases after examining the interests of all parties.

Written by:
Sonali Ray.

2 Comments

  • November 11, 2026

    Mansi

    Indeed very informational

  • November 11, 2026

    Shubhi

    I think law is ever changing and the law on DNA testing is just one example.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *