Disclosure Statement: Section 23 BSA, 2023

Introduction 

A disclosure statement is an important aspect of criminal investigation, particularly when  information provided by an accused person leads to the discovery of a relevant fact or  material connected with an offence. Generally, confessions made by an accused to the  police are not admissible in evidence. However, the law recognises a limited exception  where information supplied by an accused in police custody results in the discovery of a  fact. This principle is incorporated under the proviso to Section 23(2) of the Bharatiya  Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), corresponding substantially to the principle earlier  contained in Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. 

Disclosure Statement CrPC

A disclosure statement refers to information given by an accused person while in police  custody which subsequently leads to the discovery of a relevant fact. For example, if an  accused informs the police that a weapon has been hidden at a particular location and  the police recover the weapon based on that information, the portion of the statement  that distinctly relates to the discovery may be admissible. 

The purpose of this rule is not to make the entire statement admissible. Only the part of  the information that distinctly relates to the fact discovered can be proved before the  court. 

Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 

This provision of the BSA deals with confessions made to police officers. Section 23(1)  provides that a confession made to a police officer cannot be proved against an  accused. Further, Section 23(2) states that a confession made by a person while in  police custody cannot ordinarily be proved unless it is made in the immediate presence  of a Magistrate. 

The proviso to Section 23(2), however, creates an important exception. When a fact is  discovered as a consequence of information received from an accused person in police  custody, the portion of the information that distinctly relates to the fact discovered may  be proved. 

Essential Conditions for Admissibility 

For a disclosure statement to be admissible under this provision, certain conditions must  generally be satisfied. The information must come from an accused person who is in  police custody, and the information must lead to the discovery of a fact. Further, there  must be a direct connection between the information supplied and the fact discovered.

Therefore, merely making a statement before the police is not sufficient. The subsequent  discovery is an essential element of the rule. 

Disclosure Statement vs Confession 

Although the terms are sometimes used together, a disclosure statement and a confession are legally different. 

Disclosure Statement Confession
Provides information that may lead to the  discovery of a fact or material object.Contains an admission of guilt or  substantially acknowledges the  commission of an offence.
Its admissibility is limited to the portion  that distinctly relates to the fact  discovered.A confession made to a police officer is  generally inadmissible under Section 23.
Its evidentiary significance arises when  the information leads to an actual  discovery.It may be admissible in circumstances  recognised by law, subject to applicable  safeguards.
It does not automatically establish the  guilt of the accused.A legally admissible confession can have  substantial evidentiary value against its  maker.

For example, if an accused says, “I hid the knife beneath a bridge,” and the police  recover the knife from that location, the part of the statement relating distinctly to the  location and discovery may be proved. However, any separate admission such as “I  used this knife to commit the offence” does not become admissible merely because the  knife was recovered. 

Evidentiary Value

The evidentiary value of a disclosure statement is therefore limited. The entire statement  does not become admissible simply because some information contained in it leads to  recovery. The court may consider only the portion that distinctly relates to the fact  discovered. 

A disclosure statement by itself is not substantive proof of guilt. Its importance lies in the  discovery resulting from the information supplied by the accused. The prosecution must  still establish the other necessary elements of the offence through legally admissible  evidence. 

Disclosure Statement and Co-Accused 

A disclosure statement made by one accused cannot ordinarily be treated as substantive  evidence against another accused merely because the other person is implicated in the 

statement. The admissibility of such information must be examined in accordance with  the statutory requirements and the facts discovered as a result of it. 

Therefore, a statement made by one accused does not automatically establish the guilt  of a co-accused. The court must examine the surrounding circumstances and the  independent evidence available on record. 

Conclusion 

The disclosure statement provision under Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya  Adhiniyam, 2023 seeks to balance the rights of an accused with the legitimate  requirements of criminal investigation. Unlike a confession, which primarily involves an  admission of guilt, a disclosure statement becomes relevant when information supplied  by an accused leads to the discovery of a fact. Even then, only the portion distinctly  connected with the discovery can be proved. 

Thus, the law prevents the unrestricted use of police confessions while allowing genuine  discoveries arising from information supplied during an investigation to be considered by  the court. A disclosure statement should therefore be assessed carefully, keeping in  mind the statutory requirements and the limited nature of its evidentiary value. 

Written by Nisha Das

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *