A son in a Mitakshara family automatically gets a share in the ancestral property by birth, while in a Dayabhaga family he doesn’t? The answer lies in the schools of Hindu law.
Hindu Law
Ancient hindu law was not developed through a single statute or a uniform legal code, Hindu law came from the Shruti and Smritis, Overtime varying interpretations of these texts by different scholars developed into schools of hindu law, the legal principles and laws accepted and followed by Hindus in different regions.
What are schools of hindu law?
School here basically means a form of interpretation, different scholars interpreted the same texts and scriptures differently and each became a separate school, i.e set of rules and laws which were accepted and followed in different regions,, it doesn’t mean they are different religions or sects, these schools are just different interpretation of hindu law.
These schools deal with civil matters of believers of the hindu religion including inheritance, succession, coparcenary, partition, settlement of family property and governing related matters.
Why did different schools develop?
Different schools of Hindu law developed because ancient religious texts were broad and open to interpretation, and scholars wrote different commentaries that adapted these rules to fit local customs, traditions, and regional socio-legal needs.
Hindu Law originally developed from Shruti – primary texts the Vedas and foundational legal and moral rules and Smritis – ancient texts that laid down rules related to conduct and duties.
Mitakshara school and Dayabhaga school of Hindu Law
In this way two main schools of hindu law came into existence :
The Mitakshara school and The Dayabhaga school.
The Mitakshara school of Hindu Law
Mitakshara is a commentary on the Yajnavalkya Smriti, written by Vijnanesvara around the 11th century. This is the principal school that prevailed throughout most of India historically, except mainly Bengal and Assam, where Dayabhaga was influential.
One of the most important features of ancient mitakshara law was the concept of right by birth in ancestral coparcenary property.
Sub-Schools of Mitakshara
The mitakshara schools has mainly 4 sub schools, mainly divided by the region they are followed in:
1. Banaras School – Historically followed in much of northern India.
2. Mithila School – Historically associated with Mithila, particularly parts of northern Bihar.
3. Maharashtra or Bombay School – Historically followed in Maharashtra and adjoining western regions.
4. Dravida or Madras School – Historically followed in southern India.
The Dayabhaga school of Hindu Law
The Dayabhaga School mainly prevailed in Bengal and Assam, Historically.
This school was authored by Jimutavahana, during the 12th century approximately,Its foundation is basically a digest of Hindu legal texts.
The main distinction of dayabhaga from mitakshara school is that under traditional Dayabhaga law, a son did not acquire an interest in ancestral property merely by birth.
The concept of interest in ancestral property merely on the basis of birth does not exist in this form of interpretation of the Hindu laws.
Instead here, the right of inheritance arose at the death of the owner i.e. in the form of succession.
Dayabhaga School of hindu law does not have any principal sub schools.
Main differences between Mitakshara and Dayabhaga school
1. Coparcenary interest – Under mitakshara the share is unified and there is no defined share until partition. However, under dayabhaga each coparcener’s share is defined and can be disposed of.
2. Meaning of Sapinda – means how kinship is defined in each school. Mitakshara follows Vijnanesvara’s Theory – “Particles of the Same Body”. The same relies on physical closeness and blood lineage-connection. Whereas in Dayabhaga, Jimutavahana’s “Oblation / Pinda Theory” is followed. It relies on spiritual and ritualistic efficacy rather than pure blood proximity.
3. Widow – Dayabhaga allows a widow to step into her husband’s position and demand share if he leaves no male descendants. On the other hand, mitakshara largely restricts a widow’s rights and she can’t become a coparcener in the same way.
4. Nature of shares – under Mitakshara system the share is fluctuating interests in coparcenary property. However, under dayabhaga shares are defined upon succession.
5. Right to joint family property- Under Mitakshara, the system of interest of a son in the ancestral property is secured by birth is followed. Under Dayabhaga, the right arises only on the death of the father, so sons have no right while he is alive.
Modern Position of Schools of Hindu Law
These schools developed in the ancient times, since then, various legislations and judicial decisions have developed the position of hindu law and the rules have been modified including the ones mentioned below:
1. The schools matter only for uncodified matters, the codified law still applies to all Hindus uniformly.
2. The major differences were removed by introduction of legislations under the Hindu Law. These include the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956.
3. The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 has replaced both schools’ rules of succession. Now there is one uniform law, the joint family system and coparcenary are not fully codified yet so the differences still operate there.
4. The 2005 amendment to Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act made daughters coparceners by birth in Mitakshara joint families.
The Supreme Court in Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020) clarified that this right applies even if the father was not alive on 9 September 2005.
Conclusion
The major distinction between the Mitakshara school and Dayabhaga school of Hindu Law lies in its approach towards inheritance and succession rights, The position of Hindu law has changed over time so are the differences among these two schools, which have narrowed down.
Codification may have erased the old differences in succession, but the Mitakshara and Dayabhaga schools still shape how Hindu joint families hold and divide property.
Written By:
Alisha Qureshi

