Article 13 of the Indian Constitution provides constitutional checks against legislation. This is because it entails the Doctrine of Eclipse and the Doctrine of Severability in Judicial Review. Doctrine of Eclipse and Severability are rules of interpretation used to scrutinise the constitutional validity of legislation. It ensures that the legislation in force is consistent with the supreme law of the land, i.e., the Constitution of India.
Constitutional foundation: Article 13
Article 13 stipulates that if any law is inconsistent with the provisions of Part III of the Constitution, it becomes void. Part III provides fundamental rights. This means all laws in force in the land must be consistent with the provisions of fundamental rights. Clause (1) of Article 13 curtails pre-Constitutional laws. Whereas, Clause (2) impedes laws that are enacted after commencement of the Constitution. Clause (1) stipulates the doctrine of eclipse, and Clause (2) the doctrine of severability

Image generated by Gemini
Doctrine of Eclipse:
Eclipsed means overshadowed. The doctrine of eclipse overshadows pre-Constitution laws after commencement of the Constitution, to the extent they contravene fundamental rights. The eclipsed part becomes void. Although Behram Khurshid Pesikaka Vs. State of Bombay (AIR/1955/SC/123), explains that the term void in the Article does not mean “repealed” and does not rescind the entire law. Then, Bhikaji Narain Dhakras Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR/1955/SC/781) judgment states that an inconsistent existing law is inoperative from the commencement of the Constitution but not dead altogether. The legislation can come into operation after amendment. Notably, this doctrine does not apply to post-constitutional laws. This was held in Mahendra Lal Jaini Vs. State of U.P. (AIR/1963/SC/1019), that the language of Clause (1) acknowledges the operation of pre-Constitutional laws after the commencement of the Constitution.
Doctrine of Severability:
Severability means the quality of being separable. Clause 2 of Article 13 provides the doctrine of Severability. It separates the valid and invalid parts of the legislation. This doctrine separates portions of enacted legislation that conflict with fundamental rights. This operates on post-constitutional laws. It makes the legislation void to the extent it becomes unconstitutional. The void part in this clause renders void ab initio. The remaining valid part of the Act remains operational. However, if the unconstitutional part is inseparable, then the whole legislation becomes invalid.
The Supreme Court in R.M.D.C. v. Union of India (AIR/1957/SC/628) laid down the rules with respect to severability of legislation:
– to determine whether the invalid portion of the statute is an integral part of it or not, the intention of the legislature will be considered;
– if separation of valid and invalid parts renders the whole legislation inoperative, then the whole statute becomes invalid or void;
– if after removal of invalid portion, the statute remains functioning, the rest of the statute becomes operative.
Eclipse vs Severability:
Both doctrines determine the constitutional validity of the statute, but they have the following fundamental difference:
| Doctrine of Severability | Doctrine of Eclipse |
| It separates the unconstitutional part from the valid part of the statute. | It overshadows or makes inoperative the unconstitutional part. |
| Applies to post-constitutional laws. | Applies to pre-constitutional laws. |
| The void part is void ab initio | The void part is overshadowed and inoperative only. |
| Under Clause 2 of Article 13 | Under Clause 1 of the Article 13 |
Conclusion:
The doctrine of Eclipse avoids the administrative inconvenience, time and resource investment in re-enactment of pre-constitutional laws. At the same time, it has made their unconstitutional provisions inoperative. However, the doctrine of Severability allows the rest of the legislation to remain operational after separating its unconstitutional portion. This prevents complete invalidation of legislation and prevents a legal vacuum. These two provisions are judicial weapons to safeguard constitutional values.
Written By:
Sonali Ray


Constructive Possession - Legal Insaan
[…] possession is a legal doctrine that treats a person as possessing an object even when they were not physically controlling it at […]